| Date | Away | Score | Home | Score | Time/Status | Links |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
February | ||||||
| Feb 18 | Messiah | 7 | Mary Washington | 6 | Final - 8 innings | Box Score |
| Messiah | 1 | Mary Washington | 6 | Final | Box Score | |
| Feb 24 | York (Pa.) | 5 | Emory & Henry | 11 | Final | Box Score |
| Salisbury | 8 | Piedmont | 1 | Final | Box Score | |
| Methodist Tournament | ||||||
| York (Pa.) | 4 | Methodist | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
| Methodist University Early Bird Tournament | ||||||
| N.C. Wesleyan | 9 | Stevenson | 4 | Final | Box Score | |
| Methodist Early Bird Tournament | ||||||
| Roanoke | 0 | Salisbury | 5 | Final | Box Score | |
| Methodist Tournament | ||||||
| Feb 25 | Stevenson | 1 | Methodist | 6 | Final | Box Score |
| Methodist Early Bird Tournament | ||||||
| Greensboro | 1 | Salisbury | 9 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score | |
| Methodist Early Bird Tournament | ||||||
| McDaniel | 2 | Mary Washington | 4 | Final | Box Score | |
| Emory & Henry | 1 | Stevenson | 2 | Final - 8 innings | Box Score | |
| Methodist Early Bird Tournament | ||||||
| Hood | 1 | Bridgewater (Va.) | 9 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score Audio | |
| Frostburg St. | 6 | Randolph-Macon | 11 | Final | Box Score | |
| York (Pa.) | 2 | Roanoke | 7 | Final | Box Score | |
| Methodist University Early Bird Tournament | ||||||
| McDaniel | 4 | Mary Washington | 3 | Final - 8 innings | Box Score | |
| Salisbury | 2 | N.C. Wesleyan | 0 | Final - 8 innings | Box Score | |
| Methodist Early Bird Tournament | ||||||
| Hood | 1 | Bridgewater (Va.) | 8 | Final | Box Score Audio | |
| Frostburg St. | 0 | Randolph-Macon | 12 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| N.C. Wesleyan | 7 | York (Pa.) | 4 | Final - 8 innings | Box Score | |
| Methodist Early Bird Tournament | ||||||
| Stevenson | 0 | Greensboro | 11 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Methodist Early Bird Tournament | ||||||
| Feb 26 | Shenandoah | 3 | Mary Washington | 0 | Final | Box Score |
| Shenandoah | 7 | Mary Washington | 4 | Final | Box Score | |
| Feb 28 | Va. Wesleyan | 12 | Mary Washington | 4 | Final | Box Score |
| Va. Wesleyan | 5 | Mary Washington | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
March | ||||||
| Mar 02 | Roanoke | 0 | Salisbury | 1 | Final | Box Score |
| Virginia Wesleyan Beach Blast | ||||||
| York (Pa.) | 6 | Lynchburg | 2 | Final | Box Score | |
| Virginia Wesleyan Beach Blast at Princess Anne Athletic Complex | ||||||
| York (Pa.) | 2 | Meredith | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
| Virginia Wesleyan Beach Blast | ||||||
| Va. Wesleyan | 2 | Stevenson | 3 | Final - 8 innings | Box Score | |
| VWC Beach Blast | ||||||
| Salisbury | 5 | Shenandoah | 6 | Final | Box Score | |
| Hood | 1 | Averett | 5 | Final | Box Score | |
| Randolph | 5 | Frostburg St. | 8 | Final | Box Score | |
| Frostburg St. | 2 | Roanoke | 10 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score | |
| Mt. St. Vincent | 1 | Hood | 9 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score | |
| Stevenson | 0 | Meredith | 1 | Final | Box Score | |
| VWC Beach Blast | ||||||
| Mar 03 | Lynchburg | Frostburg St. | Postponed | |||
| Hood | Rutgers-Newark | Cancelled | ||||
| Frostburg St. | Averett | Cancelled | ||||
| Hood | Allegheny | Cancelled | ||||
| Stevenson | Randolph | Cancelled | ||||
| VWC Beach Blast | ||||||
| Mar 05 | Wesley | 15 | Wentworth | 5 | Final | Box Score |
| La Roche | 4 | Mary Washington | 11 | Final - 7 innings | Box Score | |
| Mary Washington | 3 | Mt. Aloysius | 0 | Final | Box Score | |
| Wentworth | 4 | Wesley | 2 | Final | Box Score | |
| Penn St.-Berks | 1 | Wesley | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mar 06 | Wesley | 10 | Penn St.-Altoona | 14 | Final | Box Score |
| Penn St.-Altoona | 15 | Wesley | 1 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Chris. Newport | 4 | Salisbury | 3 | Final | Video Box Score | |
| Mary Washington | 11 | Gwynedd-Mercy | 1 | Final | Box Score | |
| Chris. Newport | 5 | Salisbury | 1 | Final | Video Box Score | |
| Gwynedd-Mercy | 1 | Mary Washington | 9 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mar 07 | Chatham | 0 | Mary Washington | 8 | Final | |
| Juniata | 3 | Wesley | 0 | Final | Box Score | |
| Blackburn | 3 | Mary Washington | 8 | Final | ||
| Penn St.-Beaver | 3 | Wesley | 11 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Mar 08 | Wesley | 6 | Juniata | 3 | Final | Box Score |
| Mary Washington | 0 | Ursinus | 6 | Final | Box Score | |
| Lynchburg | 0 | Salisbury | 9 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Hood | 6 | Wilson | 4 | Final | Box Score | |
| Blackburn | 1 | Mary Washington | 9 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Lynchburg | 1 | Salisbury | 4 | Final | Box Score | |
| Hood | Wilson | Cancelled | ||||
| Mar 09 | Wilkes | 4 | Stevenson | 5 | Final | Box Score |
| Sea Gull Classic | ||||||
| Wilkes | 2 | Frostburg St. | 8 | Final | ||
| Stevenson | 2 | Lynchburg | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
| Sea Gull Classic | ||||||
| Washington & Jefferson | 0 | Salisbury | 6 | Final | Video Box Score | |
| Sea Gull Classic | ||||||
| Susquehanna | 0 | Salisbury | 6 | Final | Video Box Score | |
| Sea Gull Classic | ||||||
| Chris. Newport | 11 | Frostburg St. | 0 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Sea Gull Invitational | ||||||
| Mar 10 | Arcadia | 3 | Stevenson | 4 | Final | Box Score |
| Sea Gull Classic | ||||||
| Frostburg St. | 3 | Susquehanna | 10 | Final | Box Score | |
| D'Youville | 0 | Salisbury | 4 | Final | Box Score | |
| Sea Gull Classic | ||||||
| Stevenson | 5 | Washington & Jefferson | 6 | Final | Box Score | |
| Sea Gull Classic | ||||||
| Wilkes | 2 | Salisbury | 1 | Final | Box Score | |
| Sea Gull Classic | ||||||
| Baruch | 1 | Frostburg St. | 10 | Final | ||
| Mar 11 | Frostburg St. * | 7 | Wesley | 0 | Final | Box Score |
| Hood | Macalester | Cancelled | ||||
| Frostburg St. * | 14 | Wesley | 5 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mar 12 | Frank. & Marsh. | 6 | Hood | 2 | Final | Box Score |
| Clermont | ||||||
| Minn.-Morris | 4 | Hood | 9 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mar 13 | Mass.-Boston | 9 | Hood | 3 | Final | |
| Stevenson | 0 | Shenandoah | 8 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Widener | 5 | Wesley | 4 | Final | Box Score | |
| Stevenson | 2 | Shenandoah | 10 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Widener | 7 | Wesley | 2 | Final | Box Score | |
| SUNY Plattsburgh | 5 | Hood | 2 | Final | Box Score | |
| Anna Maria | 2 | Hood | 5 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mar 14 | Va. Wesleyan | 2 | Salisbury | 0 | Final | Video Box Score |
| Wesley | 13 | Lehman | 4 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Va. Wesleyan | 2 | Salisbury | 4 | Final | Video Box Score | |
| Wesley | 17 | Lehman | 6 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Mar 15 | Mount Ida | 3 | Hood | 4 | Final | Box Score |
| Macalester | 9 | Hood | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
| Stevenson | 0 | Catholic | 4 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mary Washington | 0 | Bridgewater (Va.) | 8 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score Audio | |
| Waynesburg | 3 | Frostburg St. | 4 | Final | ||
| Stevenson | 9 | Catholic | 0 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Mary Washington | 1 | Bridgewater (Va.) | 2 | Final | Box Score Audio | |
| Waynesburg | 6 | Frostburg St. | 3 | Final | ||
| Mar 16 | Grove City | 0 | Salisbury | 6 | Final | Video Box Score |
| Salisbury Invitational | ||||||
| Capital | 2 | Salisbury | 10 | Final | Video Box Score | |
| Salisbury Invitational | ||||||
| Western Conn. St. | 5 | Hood | 0 | Final | Box Score | |
| Bowdoin | 5 | Hood | 4 | Final | Box Score | |
| NTC Spring Games | ||||||
| Mar 17 | Grove City | 0 | Salisbury | 8 | Final | Video Box Score |
| Salisbury Invitational | ||||||
| York (Pa.) | 0 | Bridgewater (Va.) | 6 | Final | Box Score Audio | |
| Eastern Mennonite | 0 | Mary Washington | 1 | Final | Box Score | |
| York (Pa.) | 0 | Bridgewater (Va.) | 2 | Final | Box Score Audio | |
| Eastern Mennonite | 8 | Mary Washington | 2 | Final | Box Score | |
| Wesley | 14 | Penn St.-Abington | 1 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| TCNJ | 0 | Salisbury | 5 | Final | Video Box Score | |
| Salisbury Invitational | ||||||
| Wesley | 16 | Penn St.-Abington | 4 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Mar 18 | York (Pa.) | 1 | Eastern Mennonite | 13 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score |
| York (Pa.) | 2 | Eastern Mennonite | 5 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mar 19 | Concordia (Wis.) | 2 | Frostburg St. | 4 | Final | Box Score |
| NTC Spring Games | ||||||
| Union (N.Y.) | 3 | Frostburg St. | 2 | Final | ||
| Penn St.-Berks | 0 | Stevenson | 8 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Penn St.-Berks | 0 | Stevenson | 8 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Mar 20 | Hope | 5 | Frostburg St. | 4 | Final - 8 innings | |
| Wesley | 12 | Gallaudet | 4 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score | |
| Hood | 7 | Eastern Mennonite | 9 | Final | Box Score | |
| Tufts | 7 | Frostburg St. | 5 | Final | ||
| Wesley | 14 | Gallaudet | 6 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mar 21 | Chris. Newport | Mary Washington | Postponed | |||
| Stevenson | 5 | Washington College | 1 | Final | Box Score Audio Audio | |
| Chris. Newport | Mary Washington | Postponed | ||||
| Stevenson | 5 | Washington College | 6 | Final | Box Score Audio Audio | |
| Mar 22 | Luther | 4 | Frostburg St. | 0 | Final | |
| Wis.-Stevens Point | 0 | Frostburg St. | 2 | Final | ||
| York (Pa.) | 3 | Susquehanna | 1 | Final | Box Score | |
| York (Pa.) | 3 | Susquehanna | 11 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Mar 23 | Frostburg St. | 5 | Colby | 4 | Final | |
| Frostburg St. | 5 | Manchester | 2 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mar 25 | Hood * | 0 | Salisbury | 9 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score |
| Hood * | 0 | Salisbury | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mar 26 | York (Pa.) * | 6 | Wesley | 1 | Final | Box Score |
| York (Pa.) * | 11 | Wesley | 5 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score | |
| Mar 27 | Catholic | 3 | Salisbury | 5 | Final | Video Box Score |
| Catholic | 7 | Salisbury | 12 | Final | Video Box Score | |
| Mar 28 | Stevenson | 1 | Randolph-Macon | 2 | Final - 9 innings | Box Score |
| Frostburg St. * | 5 | York (Pa.) | 2 | Final | Box Score | |
| Hood * | 1 | Mary Washington | 14 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Stevenson | 0 | Randolph-Macon | 1 | Final - 8 innings | Box Score | |
| Hood * | 0 | Mary Washington | 5 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score | |
| Frostburg St. * | 1 | York (Pa.) | 0 | Final - 8 innings | Box Score | |
| Mar 29 | Chris. Newport | 2 | Mary Washington | 3 | Final | Box Score |
| Chris. Newport | 9 | Mary Washington | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mar 30 | York (Pa.) * | 6 | Hood | 2 | Final | Box Score |
| Salisbury * | 8 | Stevenson | 0 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score Audio | |
| York (Pa.) * | 3 | Hood | 2 | Final | Box Score | |
| Salisbury * | 8 | Stevenson | 2 | Final | Box Score Audio | |
| Mar 31 | Wesley * | 0 | Mary Washington | 9 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score |
| Salisbury * | 10 | Frostburg St. | 1 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Wesley * | 0 | Mary Washington | 8 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score | |
| Salisbury * | 11 | Frostburg St. | 2 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score | |
April | ||||||
| Apr 01 | Wesley * | 1 | Hood | 6 | Final | Box Score |
| Mary Baldwin | 0 | Stevenson | 8 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Wesley * | 6 | Hood | 2 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mary Baldwin | 0 | Stevenson | 8 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score | |
| Apr 02 | York (Pa.) | 2 | Messiah | 9 | Final | Box Score |
| Rosemont | 3 | Wesley | 6 | Final | Box Score | |
| York (Pa.) | 0 | Messiah | 8 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Rosemont | 2 | Wesley | 10 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Apr 03 | Mary Washington * | 5 | York (Pa.) | 3 | Final | Box Score |
| Hood | 0 | Gettysburg | 9 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score | |
| Mary Washington * | 5 | York (Pa.) | 1 | Final | Box Score | |
| Hood | 6 | Gettysburg | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
| Apr 04 | Wesley | 6 | Briarcliffe (N.Y.) | 9 | Final | Box Score |
| Wesley | 3 | Briarcliffe (N.Y.) | 3 | Final - 7 innings | Box Score | |
| Apr 05 | Randolph-Macon | 11 | Mary Washington | 4 | Final | Box Score |
| Randolph-Macon | 5 | Mary Washington | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
| Frostburg St. | 7 | Dickinson | 6 | Final | Box Score | |
| Frostburg St. | 9 | Dickinson | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
| Apr 06 | Hood * | 0 | Stevenson | 8 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score |
| Hood * | 0 | Stevenson | 6 | Final | Box Score | |
| Apr 07 | Salisbury * | 8 | Mary Washington | 0 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score |
| Stevenson * | 4 | Frostburg St. | 6 | Final | Box Score | |
| Salisbury * | 7 | Mary Washington | 2 | Final | Box Score | |
| Stevenson * | 1 | Frostburg St. | 12 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Apr 09 | Penn St.-Altoona | 6 | York (Pa.) | 1 | Final | Box Score |
| Messiah | 9 | Hood | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
| Penn St.-Altoona | 3 | York (Pa.) | 7 | Final | Box Score | |
| Messiah | 10 | Hood | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
| Apr 10 | Mary Washington * | 8 | Stevenson | 2 | Final | Box Score |
| Wesley * | 0 | Salisbury | 15 | Final - 5 innings | Video Box Score | |
| Mary Washington * | 4 | Stevenson | 3 | Final | Box Score | |
| Wesley * | 0 | Salisbury | 8 | Final - 5 innings | Video Box Score | |
| Apr 11 | Mary Washington | 12 | Mary Baldwin | 1 | Final - 7 innings | Box Score |
| Stevenson * | 1 | York (Pa.) | 8 | Final | Box Score | |
| Salisbury | 10 | Washington College | 1 | Final | Box Score Audio | |
| Frostburg St. * | 4 | Hood | 13 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score | |
| Mary Washington | 14 | Mary Baldwin | 0 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Stevenson * | 3 | York (Pa.) | 7 | Final | Box Score | |
| Salisbury | 5 | Washington College | 0 | Final | Box Score Audio | |
| Frostburg St. * | 13 | Hood | 3 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Apr 12 | York (Pa.) | 4 | Misericordia | 3 | Final | Box Score |
| York (Pa.) | 5 | Misericordia | 14 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Apr 13 | Hood | 4 | Mt. Aloysius | 8 | Final | Box Score |
| Hood | 6 | Mt. Aloysius | 8 | Final | Box Score | |
| Apr 14 | York (Pa.) * | 0 | Salisbury | 8 | Final - 6 innings | Video Box Score |
| Stevenson * | 6 | Wesley | 1 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mary Washington * | 2 | Frostburg St. | 0 | Final | Box Score | |
| York (Pa.) * | 1 | Salisbury | 9 | Final - 5 innings | Video Box Score | |
| Stevenson * | 5 | Wesley | 0 | Final | Box Score | |
| Mary Washington * | 4 | Frostburg St. | 13 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Apr 15 | Catholic | 7 | Hood | 6 | Final - 11 innings | Box Score |
| Frostburg St. | 7 | Washington & Jefferson | 0 | Final | ||
| Catholic | 6 | Hood | 0 | Final | Box Score | |
| Washington & Jefferson | 6 | Frostburg St. | 7 | Final | ||
| Apr 17 | Arcadia | 5 | Wesley | 1 | Final | Box Score |
| Stevenson | 1 | Mary Washington | 2 | Final | Box Score | |
| York (Pa.) | 3 | Frostburg St. | 5 | Final | Box Score | |
| Capital Athletic Conference Tournament First Round | ||||||
| Hood | 0 | Salisbury | 12 | Final - 5 innings | Video Box Score | |
| CAC First Round | ||||||
| Arcadia | 7 | Wesley | 6 | Final | Box Score | |
| Apr 19 | Wesley | 21 | Valley Forge Chrst. | 1 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score |
| York (Pa.) | 1 | Salisbury | 5 | Final | Video Box Score | |
| CAC Tournament | ||||||
| Hood | 1 | Stevenson | 9 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| CAC Second Round | ||||||
| Frostburg St. | 0 | Mary Washington | 8 | Final - 5 innings | ||
| Wesley | 14 | Valley Forge Chrst. | 1 | Final - 5 innings | Box Score | |
| Apr 21 | Mary Washington | 0 | Salisbury | 3 | Final | Video Box Score |
| CAC Tournament | ||||||
| Stevenson | 3 | Frostburg St. | 6 | Final | Box Score | |
| CAC Semifinals | ||||||
| Mary Washington | 1 | Frostburg St. | 2 | Final | ||
| Apr 25 | Mary Washington | 3 | Catholic | 4 | Final | Box Score |
| McDaniel | 1 | Stevenson | 2 | Final - 10 innings | Box Score Audio | |
| Washington College | 3 | York (Pa.) | 4 | Final - 8 innings | Box Score | |
| Mary Washington | 4 | Catholic | 8 | Final | Box Score | |
| McDaniel | 3 | Stevenson | 5 | Final | Box Score Audio | |
| Washington College | 2 | York (Pa.) | 7 | Final | Box Score | |
| Apr 26 | McDaniel | 3 | Hood | 2 | Final | Box Score |
| Stevenson | 2 | Albright | 1 | Final - 8 innings | Box Score | |
| McDaniel | 5 | Hood | 1 | Final | Box Score | |
| Stevenson | 5 | Albright | 2 | Final | Box Score | |
| Apr 27 | York (Pa.) | 0 | Shenandoah | 8 | Final - 6 innings | Box Score |
| York (Pa.) | 7 | Shenandoah | 8 | Final - 10 innings | Box Score | |
| Apr 28 | Frostburg St. | 1 | Salisbury | 9 | Final - 5 innings | Video Box Score |
| CAC Tournament | ||||||
| Apr 29 | Frostburg St. | 8 | Catholic | 9 | Final | Box Score |
| Frostburg St. | 3 | Catholic | 5 | Final | Box Score | |
May | ||||||
| May 02 | McDaniel | 4 | York (Pa.) | 2 | Final - 8 innings | Box Score |
| McDaniel | 2 | York (Pa.) | 5 | Final | Box Score | |
| May 10 | Ferrum | 5 | Salisbury | 2 | Final | Video Box Score |
| 2012 NCAA Tournament | ||||||
| May 11 | Salisbury | 11 | Farmingdale State | 0 | Final | Video Box Score |
| 2012 NCAA Tournament | ||||||
| May 12 | Salisbury | 2 | Emory | 0 | Final | Video Box Score |
| 2012 NCAA Tournament | ||||||
| May 13 | Salisbury | 2 | McDaniel | 4 | Final | Video Box Score |
| NCAA Regional Tournament | ||||||
* Conference